DEFEATING JUNK SCIENCE: ARTICLE BY JULIE KILLINGSWORTH WARNS MEDICAL SCIENCE OF “..A DESTRUCTIVE IDEOLOGICAL CRUSADE THAT PRIORITIZES ANTI-NARCOTIC ZEALOTRY.” MARK-TIME; Edition-2

“..you cannot set a boundary and simultaneously take care of someone else’s feelings..”

dr. mark ibsen, md

reported by

youarewithinthenorms.com

NORMAN J CLEMENT RPH., DDS, NORMAN L. CLEMENT PHARM-TECH, MALACHI F. MACKANDAL PHARMD, BELINDA BROWN-PARKER, IN THE SPIRIT OF JOSEPH SOLVO ESQ., INC., SPIRIT OF REV. IN THE SPIRIT OF WALTER R. CLEMENT BS., MS, MBA. HARVEY JENKINS, MD, PH.D., IN THE SPIRIT OF C.T. VIVIAN, JELANI ZIMBABWE CLEMENT, BS., M.B.A., IN THE SPIRIT OF THE HON. PATRICE LUMUMBA, IN THE SPIRIT OF ERLIN CLEMENT SR., EVELYN J. CLEMENT, IN THE SPIRIT OF WALTER F. WRENN III., MD., JULIE KILLINGSWORTH, RENEE BLARE, RPH, DR. TERENCE SASAKI, MD LESLY POMPY MD., CHRISTOPHER RUSSO, MD., NANCY SEEFELDT, IN THE SPIRIT OF WILLIE GUINYARD BS., JOSEPH WEBSTER MD., MBA, BEVERLY C. PRINCE MD., FACS., NEIL ARNAND, MD., RICHARD KAUL, MD., IN THE SPIRIT OF LEROY BAYLOR, JAY K. JOSHI MD., MBA, AISHA GARDNER, ADRIENNE EDMUNDSON, ESTER HYATT PH.D., WALTER L. SMITH BS., IN THE SPIRIT OF BRAHM FISHER ESQ., MICHELE ALEXANDER MD., CUDJOE WILDING BS, MARTIN NJOKU, BS., RPH., IN THE SPIRIT OF DEBRA LYNN SHEPHERD, BERES E. MUSCHETT, STRATEGIC ADVISORS

JULIE KILLIGSWORTH: EMINENCE-BASED SCIENCE

In this searing critique, Julie Killingsworth denounces the 2016 CDC opioid prescribing guidelines as evidence-based junk science driven by academic ego rather than rigorous clinical evidence. She argues that influential figures like Dr. Jane Ballantyne, MD

2016 CDC OPIOID PRESCRIBING GUIDELINES AS EVIDENCE-BASED JUNK SCIENCE

In this searing critique, Julie Killingsworth denounces the 2016 CDC opioid prescribing guidelines as evidence-based junk science driven by academic ego rather than rigorous clinical evidence. She argues that influential figures like Jane Ballantyne have weaponized flawed data and arbitrary definitions to conflate legitimate chronic pain management with addiction, effectively abandoning vulnerable patients.

A graphic titled 'The High Price of Eminence-Based Junk Science' highlights a patient-led audit of the 2016 CDC prescription guidelines, with a background of blurred clinical trial papers.
JULIE KILINGSWORTH: The High Price of Eminence-Based Junk Science highlights a patient-led audit of the 2016 CDC prescription guidelines, with a background of blurred clinical trial papers.

By highlighting the lack of recent practical experience among the guidelines’ authors, Killingsworth suggests that these policies represent a destructive ideological crusade that prioritizes anti-narcotic zealotry over the lived reality of incurable suffering.

Infographic titled 'Policy Pipeline' illustrating the stages from Eminence-Based Bias to Weaponized as Law, featuring key phrases and commentary on the implications of suggestions in public policy.
‘Policy Pipeline’ illustrating the stages from Eminence-Based Bias to Weaponized as Law, featuring key phrases and commentary on the implications of suggestions in public policy.

Julie Killingsworth’s argument serves as a call to expose the corruption and dehumanization inherent in medical protocols that treat complex physical diseases with “shady” academic guesswork.

DEFEATING JUNK SCIENCE IN THE COURTROOM

Dr. Mark Ibsen, Marking Time

DR. MARK IBSEN, MD
Cover of 'Doctor Bison's Fables' featuring a bison in a white coat as a doctor, treating an otter in a medical office, with another animal reading a clipboard.
Ibsen: Once upon a time, there lived a bison who wanted to help other animals, and so spent his life studying medicine to become a doctor. So it was that the bison came upon a family of mice who were all sick, but they had nothing with which to pay for the doctor’s aid. “But without my care, your children will die. I must help, it is my duty,” he said.
Without a thought, the doctor gave them his aid, one after the other, and each mouse he healed was grateful. Soon, however, he began to tire and eventually became exhausted, yet more mice kept coming. “Surely, though, this deed will be worth it in the end,” he thought, and strengthened his resolve.

BOB SHEERIN, AIR FORCE VETERAN Andrew Hohenthaner, DR. MARK IBSEN, MD, GO TO WASHINGTON, D.C. TO DEFEAT D.E.A., CDC, FBI EMINENCE BASED USE OF JUNK SCIENCE

Three men smiling together in a hotel room, with one man in the foreground taking a selfie and two others in the background wearing caps and matching shirts.
Dr. Mark S Ibsen, MD: Lawful Malpractice Failing Our Oath to Relief Suffering a Vast Waste Land for Pain Management
Infographic titled 'Legalized Extortion: The Systemic Targeting of Black Doctors', outlining a 30-year government campaign against medical professionals of color.
An infographic titled ‘Legalized Extortion: The Systemic Targeting of Black Doctors’ outlines a 30-year government campaign against medical professionals of color.

Angela Greene

Impact on Doctors and Patients: anatomy of a constitutional failure

The consequences of this targeting extend beyond the destruction of medical careers and include significant human suffering:

Infographic titled 'The Anatomy of a Constitutional Failure' discussing issues with Dr. Timothy King's forensic scoring system, highlighting three critical failures: 'The Illusion of Science', 'Systemic Blindness', and 'Suppressed Truth'.
‘The Anatomy of a Constitutional Failure’ discussing issues with Dr. Timothy King’s forensic scoring system, highlighting three critical failures: ‘The Illusion of Science’, ‘Systemic Blindness’, and ‘Suppressed Truth’.

Patient Harm: Restrictive guidelines and the criminalization of clinical work have been linked to patient suicides, such as the case of Dr. Charles Syzman. Other uncounted metrics include patients losing basic functionality, economic displacement due to lost therapeutic access, and medical complications like strokes caused by forced medication tapers.

A document highlighting issues of racial indifference in medical treatment and discussing how government actions adversely affect minority practitioners and patients. Key points include the extortion of minority practitioners and systemic failures of physicians to believe minority patients' pain reports.
A document highlighting issues of racial indifference in medical treatment and discussing how government actions adversely affect minority practitioners and patients. Key points include the extortion of minority practitioners and systemic failures of physicians to believe minority patients’ pain reports.

Destruction of Minority Healthcare: The targeting of Black doctors creates an imminent risk to the health of the Black community, which loses providers who look like them and understand their needs.

Cover of the book 'Legalized Extortion' by Angela Greene, highlighting the theme of healthcare disparities for doctors of color and its impact on the Black community.
In her book and upcoming documentary, Angela Greene exposes a systematic campaign of racial injustice where the government allegedly weaponized the legal system to target medical professionals of color. The targeting of medical professionals, as described in the sources, is characterized by a systematic shift from administrative oversight to aggressive criminal prosecution, often specifically impacting particularly Black doctors and other practitioners of color. This phenomenon was identified by one former U.S Justice Department Attorney who described the process as a form of “legalized extortion.
Junk Science is Convicting Innocent Doctors
Infographic titled 'The High Price of Eminence-Based Science: Flaws in the CDC Opioid Guidelines' detailing issues with the CDC guidelines, including low-tier evidence standards, lack of clinical practice, missing pain expertise, average estimated rates of misuse and addiction, and inconsistent prevalence rates.
JULIE KILLINGSWORTH INFOGRAPHIC TITLED:
‘The High Price of Eminence-Based Science: Flaws in the CDC Opioid Guidelines’ details issues with the CDC guidelines, including low-tier evidence standards, lack of clinical practice, missing pain expertise, average estimated rates of misuse and addiction, and inconsistent prevalence rates.
Graphic promoting 'The Truth Button: Restoring Science to Pain Management' featuring a red circle on a grid background, with text discussing institutional fear and evidence-based medicine.
TOUCH TRUTH BUTTON BELOW ON MIS-TREATED

MISTREATED

King, Ballantyne, & Sullivan, the proponents, PERPETRATORS, and chiefs of EMINENCE-BASED junk science

A smiling man with short gray hair wearing a red polo shirt against a gray background.
DONALD R. SULLIVAN RPH., PHD.
Donald R. Sullivan, Professor at Ohio State University College of Pharmacy, never appears to have examined or interviewed the patients or prescribing physicians and relies on Junk Science in their Courtroom testimonies.
DEA Targets Pharmacies Not Cartels 15:41 MOVING THE GOALPOST:
Donald R. Sullivan, a Professor at the Ohio State University College of Pharmacy, never appears to have examined or interviewed the patients or prescribing physicians, and relies on Junk Science in their courtroom testimony.
A man in a black suit and red tie standing outdoors, with trees blurred in the background.
DR. TIMOTHY E. KING, MD “Timothy King, commonly referred to as the “RAT KING,” stands as a testament to the depths to which certain individuals will sink to satisfy their personal agendas.”
Algorithmic Justice The Timothy King Case and AI Bias in Healthcare
Smiling woman with short, wavy gray hair, wearing a navy blue top, against a kitchen background.
Dr. Jane C Ballantyne, MD, FRCA
Dr. Jane Ballantyne, MD., Pain Patients Fight CDC Opioid Guidelines

The 2016 CDC Prescription Guidelines are described by incurable disabled activists as the “most loathed document in American history,

A close-up portrait of a woman with curly hair, smiling softly while lying on a textured surface.
JUlie Killingsworth

According to Julie Killingsworth’s research observation and summary assessments;

Jane Ballantyne, an academic at the University of Washington and a central architect of the 2016 CDC Prescription Guidelines, is a figure of intense criticism in the sources. While proponents view her as a “globally renowned expert,” the provided text characterizes her as an “unscrupulous busybody” and an “anti-narcotic zealot” whose work is based on “Eminence-Based Junk Science” rather than objective clinical data.

“..I was an early advocate for restraint in opioid prescribing for chronic pain and have continued to focus my teaching and research on the clinical implications of evolving opioid science..” ..Jane Ballantyne, MD.

The 2016 CDC Prescription Guidelines are described by incurable disabled activists as the “most loathed document in American history,” causing what they characterize as widespread destruction to the lives of patients with chronic conditions.

Crowded emergency medical room with numerous patients and overwhelmed staff
Medical staff attend to numerous injured patients in a chaotic emergency setting.

The criticism of Ballantyne focuses on several key areas:

Lack of Recent Clinical Experience. A primary criticism is that Ballantyne’s authority is based on her prestige (eminence) rather than current practice. The source asserts that she:

  • Has not been board certified since 1997.
  • Has not been “within arms reach of an actual patient in decades”.
  • Relied on academic standards for the CDC guidelines that were “barely acceptable for a college thesis”.
A man with a mustache and beard, wearing a colorful striped shirt, standing outdoors with green trees and reddish soil in the background.
PAIN ON TRIAL: JOSEPH ZOLOT MD., 
“A federal jury 2015 in Boston acquitted former Dr. Joseph Zolot and nurse Lisa Pliner on Friday of conspiracy and drug trafficking charges. Prosecutors alleged the two improperly distributed methadone, oxycodone, and fentanyl, and ignored evidence that some of their patients were misusing, abusing, and even selling the drugs. Six of their patients died.”

Winging It” and Arbitrary Labeling, The author accuses Ballantyne of failing to do the “intensive labor” of gathering real evidence from actual patients, choosing instead to “wing it” when defining the boundaries between pain and addiction.

  • The “Large Gray Zone”: In her own commentary, Ballantyne admits that distinguishing between misuse, abuse, and addiction in chronic pain is a “debatably impossible task”.
  • Creating OUD and CPOD: To bridge this gap, the source claims she “made up” labels like Opioid Use Disorder (OUD) and Complex Persistent Opioid Dependence (CPOD).
  • Arbitrary Categorization: The author compares her method of lumping pain patients and addicts together to “Winston Churchill dividing up the Middle East over a cigar and a glass of whiskey.”

Dehumanization of Chronic Pain Patients

The Killingworth et al. argue that Ballantyne’s ideology is rooted in “reactionary… medical nonsense” that treats patients with incurable conditions as “raving needle-hanging out-of-the-arm drug addicts.” By suggesting that persistent dependence is “akin to addiction” and “worthy of addiction-type treatment,” Ballantyne is accused of making a “bigoted judgment call” that ignores the reality of those seeking relief from genuine physical suffering.

Alleged Conflicts of Interest

Killingworth, Ibsen, Lawhern, youarewithinthenorms.com, et. al., level serious allegations regarding Ballantyne’s motivations and financial ties:

  • Institutional Corruption: She is described as having been “paid handsomely” by former CDC Director Tom Frieden to “redefine the definition of what qualifies as scientific evidence”.
  • Industry Links: The author alleges she has a “suspicious agenda” connected to the global pharmaceutical giant Reckitt Benckiser Group and “really shady law firms.”

Impact on Patient Lives

The author, an “Incurable Disabled Activist,” claims that Ballantyne’s “innuendos” and the resulting CDC guidelines have “destroyed more lives than the Spanish Flu”. The criticism concludes that her protocols have been weaponized as law, stripping millions of Americans of their quality of life by treating their medical needs as criminal or addictive behavior

Text graphic announcing the not guilty verdict with the statement ' 38 COUNTS. 2.5 DAYS OF DELIBERATION. NOT GUILTY ON ALL.'
RAILROADED:
Graphic announcing the not-guilty verdict with the statement ‘38 COUNTS.’ 2.5 DAYS OF DELIBERATION. NOT GUILTY ON ALL

unbedside manner and the attack on Dr. Lesly pompy md

The Defense Blueprint: Lessons for Federal Medical Litigation

The total acquittal of Dr. Lesly Pompy on all counts—secured after a mere 24 hours of jury deliberation—provides a comprehensive blueprint for defending physicians against federal indictment. The defense successfully synthesized medical expertise, patient narrative, and a proactive legal stance to defeat the government’s theory.

Infographic titled 'The Framework: A Blueprint for Federal Medical Litigation' highlighting three directives with tactics and strategic values. Directive 1 focuses on the legal preparedness model, Directive 2 addresses the evidentiary loop in comprehensive care, and Directive 3 discusses the financial counter-narrative related to insurance integration.
‘The Framework: A Blueprint for Federal Medical Litigation’ highlights three directives with tactics and strategic values. Directive 1 focuses on the legal preparedness model, Directive 2 addresses the evidentiary loop in comprehensive care, and Directive 3 discusses the financial counter-narrative related to insurance integration.

Strategic Takeaways for Legal Professionals

  1. The “Law School” Preparedness Model: Dr. Pompy’s decision to attend law school while under indictment was a pivotal psychological asset. His proactive study of the system signaled a profound “consciousness of innocence,” contradicting the typical behavior of a defendant hiding from his actions.
  2. The “Comprehensive Care” Evidence Loop: The defense utilized Dr. Pompy’s treatment of routine illnesses (hypertension, diabetes, infections) to create an evidentiary loop. This made the “pill mill” allegation mathematically and clinically improbable; criminal enterprises do not invest time in managing chronic metabolic diseases.
  3. The Financial Counter-Narrative: By accepting Medicare and Medicaid and operating within the insurance infrastructure, the defense destroyed the “greed” motive. Legitimate billing practices serve as an essential defense against the “pay-to-play” allegations central to federal “pill mill” cases.
A courtroom scene featuring wooden benches with the text 'Not Guilty' and 'Full Acquittal' in bold white font.
NOT GUILTY

Despite the “Not Guilty” verdict, the Pompy case remains a harrowing reminder of the cost of victory. Dr. Pompy faced financial ruin, with legal defense costs reaching up to $ 1 million and the total destruction of a practice he had spent decades building.

A man wearing a blue cap with a yellow 'M' logo, smiling and making a peace sign, standing near a vehicle.
CHRISTOPHER RUSSO, MD, a graduate of the University of Michigan Medical School. He completed his residency in Anesthesiology at Ann Arbor, did a two-year fellowship in Pain Medicine at the University of South Florida, and a post-fellowship in Advanced Interventional Pain Techniques at Moffit Cancer Center in Tampa, Florida. He and his co-defendants were indicted in a thirty-seven-page indictment. He was indicted on five counts of health care fraud, aiding and abetting. and found “Not Guilty.”

His patients were the collateral damage of a system that faces no accountability for the lives it disrupts. In the federal medical arena, a “Not Guilty” verdict is a triumph of law, but it is not yet “Justice.” True justice requires a system that stops the “railroading” of innocent physicians before the damage becomes irreversible.

dr. muhammed aly rifai, md clinical Psychiatrist

Book cover of 'USA v RAJ' featuring a blue background with a man's face, depicting a narrative about false arrests and imprisonment scandals.
RAJ BOTHRA, ALY RIFAI
A glamorous figure in a red gown stands on the red carpet at the Cannes Film Festival, accompanied by attendees in formal attire. The image features promotional text for the festival, including its dates and highlights.
A collage featuring five men and women, each in individual portraits, showcasing diverse expressions and styles.
Kabir Bedi will star as Dr. Raj Bothra in “USA v Raj,” a biographical drama directed by Ravi K. Chandran. The film, based on Bothra’s book, chronicles his three-and-a-half-year imprisonment and acquittal on 54 federal charges. The production, currently in pre-production, will film in the U.K. and India. “Not Guilty”

According to Attorney Ronald Chapman, by rigorously applying these tests, the legal strategist ensures that the courtroom remains a sanctuary for truth rather than a stage for methodologically unvalidated advocacy.

An illustration featuring a hand gently cradling a glowing figure, with a background of abstract, fragmented buildings. The text reads 'All watched over by machines of loving grace' and discusses the need for policy reform in patient care.
ALL WATCHED OVER BY MACHINES OF LOVING GRACE

🔓 🔓 🔓 

ALL WATCHED OVER BY MACHINES OF LOVING GRACE

Close-up image of a person's face with short, wavy hair and visible blue eyes.
Graphic promoting donations for legal defense, featuring the title 'You Are Within The Norms', website link, and donation methods including Zelle and Cash App.
DONATION

OUR TREE OF KNOWLEDGE SHALL NEVER BE SUPPRESSED

A diagram illustrating the 'Tree of Knowledge System' featuring various branches, including Culture, Mind, Life, and Matter, and their relation to the fields of Social Sciences, Psychology, Biology, and Physical Sciences.
The Tree of Knowledge System
Text graphic emphasizing the importance of eliminating the Controlled Substances Act (CSA) to address public health issues and inhumane treatment of patients.

FOR NOW

YOU ARE WITHIN YOUAREWITHINTHENORMS.COM, LOW VEINS TIDE

THE NORMS

REFERENCES:

https://www.facebook.com/share/v/1Eii1TikFg

Cover of the children's book 'Doctor Harvey Goes To Jail' by H. Jenkins, MD, featuring a cartoon doctor in front of a courthouse.
Harvey Jenkins, MD, a Harvard-trained orthopedic surgeon, was arrested and forced to plead guilty to 29 felony lies and received no prison time
Group of eight people posing for a photo with 'USA v RAJ' theme, featuring a stylish interior backdrop. The text on the image emphasizes the electric energy of the moment.
USA vs RAJ

Leave a Reply