TUESDAY, MARCH 25, 2025: PHYSICIANS AGAINST ABUSE AMICUS CURIAE BRIEF FILED BEFORE UNITED STATES SUPREME COURT CASE 20-1410, TURNS AUSA ARUN BODAPATI PROSECUTION ON ITS HEAD IN THE CASE OF UNITED STATES v. DR. NEIL ANAND, MD., ET AL.

NORMAN J CLEMENT RPH., DDS, NORMAN L. CLEMENT PHARM-TECH, MALACHI F. MACKANDAL PHARMD, BELINDA BROWN-PARKER, IN THE SPIRIT OF JOSEPH SOLVO ESQ., INC., SPIRIT OF REV. IN THE SPIRIT OF WALTER R. CLEMENT BS., MS, MBA. HARVEY JENKINS, MD, PH.D., IN THE SPIRIT OF C.T. VIVIAN, JELANI ZIMBABWE CLEMENT, BS., M.B.A., IN THE SPIRIT OF THE HON. PATRICE LUMUMBA, IN THE SPIRIT OF ERLIN CLEMENT SR., EVELYN J. CLEMENT, WALTER F. WRENN III., MD., JULIE KILLINGSWORTH, RENEE BLARE, RPH, DR. TERENCE SASAKI, MD LESLY POMPY MD., CHRISTOPHER RUSSO, MD., NANCY SEEFELDT, WILLIE GUINYARD BS., JOSEPH WEBSTER MD., MBA, BEVERLY C. PRINCE MD., FACS., NEIL ARNAND, MD., RICHARD KAUL, MD., IN THE SPIRIT OF LEROY BAYLOR, JAY K. JOSHI MD., MBA, AISHA GARDNER, ADRIENNE EDMUNDSON, ESTER HYATT PH.D., WALTER L. SMITH BS., IN THE SPIRIT OF BRAHM FISHER ESQ., MICHELE ALEXANDER MD., CUDJOE WILDING BS, MARTIN NJOKU, BS., RPH., IN THE SPIRIT OF DEBRA LYNN SHEPHERD, BERES E. MUSCHETT, STRATEGIC ADVISORS

[ (A-I) (alg*)= (AS) ]  

Dr. Xiulu Ruan, MD.. Pain Management Specialist, 25 years, Federal Prison
“Physicians Against Abuse in Supreme Court of The United States Case 20-1410 Ruan v. United States.” The brief asserts that criminal liability in these cases should not be based on differing opinions of hired experts and that federal prosecutions should require a criminal referral from the relevant state medical board.

PROSECUTORS USED ENTIRE DAY WHERE THEY HAVE NO AUTHORITY: BROWBEATING ANAND’S PATIENTS ON SCOPE OF PROFESSIONAL PRACTICE

This legal document is an amicus curiae brief filed by Physicians Against Abuse (PAA) to support Xiulu Ruan, a petitioner, before the United States Supreme Court.

The brief argues against the current trend of federal prosecutors bringing criminal charges against physicians for alleged over-prescription of controlled substances based solely on differing expert opinions without a criminal referral from state medical boards.

https://www.facebook.com/share/p/1AaJZr1xhV

The brief contends that this practice represents federal overreach into the state-regulated practice of medicine, leading to the mass incarceration of physicians in the US. Physicians Against Abuse advocates for a requirement that federal prosecutors obtain a criminal referral from state medical boards before initiating such prosecutions and believes the Supreme Court’s decision in Ruan’s case should be applied retroactively.

AUSA ARUN BODAPATI

TURNING BODAPATI’S CASE IN UNITED STATES v. DR NEIL ANAND, MD, ON ITS HEAD

The Physicians Against Abuse urges the Supreme Court to consider the significant problems with federal prosecutors determining the “scope of professional practice” without input from state medical boards.

DR. TIMOTHY E. KING, MD “Timothy King, commonly referred to as the “RAT KING,” stands as a testament to the depths to which certain individuals will sink to satisfy their personal agendas.”

They advocate for a system that requires a criminal referral from these state bodies before federal prosecution can commence. The brief concludes that eliminating federal prosecutions based solely on federal experts‘ opinions would respect states’ traditional role in regulating medical practice and would be a more just approach.

They also advocate for any favorable ruling in Ruan to be applied retroactively to address the numerous cases they believe are based on flawed premises.

JUSTICE RUTH BADER GINSBURG NOTORIOUS R.B.G.

This amicus curiae brief, filed by Physicians Against Abuse (PAA), supports the petitioner, Dr. Xiulu Ruan, arguing against his conviction for overprescribing controlled substances.

The PAA contends that federal prosecutors’ “scope of practice” prosecutions are fundamentally flawed and represent an overreach of federal authority into areas traditionally regulated by state medical boards.

Dr. Xiulu Ruan, MD.. Pain Management Specialist, serving 25 years in Federal Prison
“Ruan and Kahn v. United States_ Controlled Substances Act Mens Rea”.

The brief asserts that criminal liability in these cases should not be based on differing opinions of hired experts and that federal prosecutions should require a criminal referral from the relevant state medical board.

Furthermore, the PAA argues that any favorable ruling in Ruan should have a full retroactive effect. The brief highlights the concerning trend of mass incarceration of physicians in the US based on these types of prosecutions, a phenomenon not seen in any other country.

Retroactive Application of Ruan’s Decision:

  • Violation of Fundamental Rights: The PAA argues that if the Supreme Court rules in favor of Ruan, that decision should have full retroactive effect because the current prosecution practices violate fundamental rights to a fair trial.
  • “Full retroactive effect should be considered by the Court due to the fact that criminal prosecutions initiated by federal prosecutors against physicians regarding charges involving scope of practice all are rooted in prosecutorial overreach violating fundamental rights of the accused to a fair trial.” (p. 9)
  • Legal Precedent: They cite Griffith v. Kentucky to support the argument that a newly declared constitutional rule should apply to criminal cases pending on direct review.
  • “See Griffith v. Kentucky, 479 U.S. 314, 107 S. Ct. 708, 93 L. Ed. 2d 649 (1987), holding that failure to apply the newly declared constitutional rule to criminal cases pending on direct review would violate basic norms of constitutional adjudication.” (p. 9)
BOTHRA DEA EYES

THE STATE OF AMERICAN HEALTHCARE: ALL THESE PHYSICIANS SEEN HERE BELOW HAVE BEEN CRIMINALLY TARGETED BY D.E.A. AS DRUG DEALERS, FACING PRISON TIME

TRIAL OF (LEFT TO RIGHT) DR. NEIL ANAND, MD, DR. MARK IBSEN, MD, DR. MOHAMMED ALY RIFIA, MD, DR. CHRISTOPHER R. RUSSO, MD CITY OF BENJAMIN FRANKLIN

Conclusion:

The Physicians Against Abuse urged the Supreme Court to consider the significant problems associated with federal prosecutors determining the “scope of professional practice” without input from state medical boards. They advocate for a system that requires a criminal referral from these state bodies before federal prosecution can commence.

The brief concludes that eliminating federal prosecutions based solely on federal experts’ opinions would respect states’ traditional role in regulating medical practice and would be a more just approach. They also advocate for any positive ruling in Ruan to be applied retroactively to address the numerous cases they believe are based on flawed premises.

BRANDY LEE CHRONIC PAIN CARE PATIENT

DONATE LEGAL DEFENSE

OR SEND

TO CASH APP:$docnorm

ZELLE 3135103378

ALL WATCHED OVER BY MACHINES OF LOVING GRACE

BE SURE TO DONATE TO THE MARK IBSEN GOFUNDME DEFENSE FUND, WHERE THE SON ALWAYS RISES!!!

Tree of knowledge system - Wikipedia
OUR KNOWLEDGE WILL NEVER BE SUPPRESSED

FOR NOW, YOU ARE WITHIN

YOUAREWITHINTHENORMS.COM, BENJAMIN CLEMENTINE “THE NEMESIS” LONDON ENGLAN 2015

THE NORMS

Briefing Document: Amicus Curiae Brief of Physicians Against Abuse in Support of Petitioner Xiulu Ruan/ APPLICABLE TO U.S. VS. DR NEIL ANAND, MD ET AL.

Case Name and Citation: Xiulu Ruan v. United States, No. 20-1410, Supreme Court of the United States

Source: Brief Amicus Curiae of Physicians Against Abuse

Date of Brief: December 27, 2021

I. Executive Summary:

This amicus curiae brief, filed by Physicians Against Abuse (PAA), supports the petitioner, Dr. Xiulu Ruan, arguing against his conviction for overprescribing controlled substances. The PAA contends that such “scope of practice” prosecutions by federal prosecutors are fundamentally flawed and represent an overreach of federal authority into areas traditionally regulated by state medical boards.

The brief asserts that criminal liability in these cases should not be based on differing opinions of hired experts and that federal prosecutions should require a criminal referral from the relevant state medical board. Furthermore, the PAA argues that any favorable ruling in Ruan should have full retroactive effect.

The brief highlights the concerning trend of mass incarceration of physicians in the US based on these types of prosecutions, a phenomenon not seen in any other country.

II. Main Themes and Important Ideas/Facts:

A. Problematic Nature of “Scope of Practice” Prosecutions:

  • Overreach of Federal Prosecutors: The PAA argues that federal prosecutors are improperly intruding into the realm of medical practice, which is traditionally and legally regulated by state medical boards. They contend that without medical expertise or direct regulatory authority over medical practice standards, federal prosecutors are ill-equipped to determine what constitutes legitimate medical purpose or falls outside the “scope of professional practice.”
  • “This case addresses an impermissible invasion of the federal government into state affairs where the practice of medicine is solely regulated by state medical boards.” (p. 3)
  • “It is not the federal government that regulates the practice of medicine and thus no federal prosecutor should be permitted to argue in court that a physician criminally violated the standard of care unless and until a criminal referral is generated by the state medical board where the accused physician practices.” (p. 3)
  • Reliance on “War of Experts”: The brief criticizes the practice of federal prosecutors hiring experts, often from different medical fields than the accused, to create criminal liability based on differing opinions regarding medical necessity or standard of care. This “war of experts,” funded by government resources, can sway juries even if the accused physician acted in what they believed to be legitimate medical practice.
  • “In analyzing the root cause of the near 99% percent success rate of convictions against physicians, PAA concluded that what it all boiled down to was a prosecutor with a hunch hiring an expert using the deep pockets of the government, often not even in the same field as the accused physician, to criminalize behavior of the accused physician.” (p. 2)
  • “‘WAR OF EXPERTS’ CANNOT BE THE BASIS OF CRIMINAL LIABILITY IN ‘SCOPE OF PRACTICE’ PROSECUTIONS” (p. 6 – Heading of Argument I)
  • Influence of Opioid Crisis and Wealth Bias: The PAA suggests that the ongoing opioid crisis creates an environment where prosecutors can easily appeal to the emotions of the jury. They also highlight a perceived tactic of portraying wealthy physicians as greedy drug pushers, unfairly influencing the jury’s perception.
  • “Relying on a three pronged approach, (1) the phrase, “not for a legitimate medical purpose”, (2) hired government expert, and (3) ability to show substantial wealth for the accused physician, federal prosecutors have been successfully getting jury to return a guilty verdict in 9 out of 10 “scope of practice” cases all over the country.” (p. 2)
  • “In nearly every one of these cases, prosecutors argue that rich doctors writing prescriptions for controlled substances with patients who are paying cash cannot possibly be for a legitimate medical purpose. And in nearly every one of these cases, first the jury and then the judge fall for it.” (p. 7)
  • Lack of Mens Rea Consideration: The brief specifically points to the Eleventh Circuit, where Ruan’s case originated, for allegedly diminishing the importance of mens rea (criminal intent) in prescription fraud cases.
  • “The Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals has fallen the hardest for this drama as it has written the necessary element of mens rea out of existence in considering charges involving prescription fraud. 21 U.S.C. § 841(a)(1).” (p. 7)

B. The Role of State Medical Boards:

  • Primary Regulators of Medical Practice: The PAA emphasizes that state medical boards are the appropriate bodies to regulate the practice of medicine, set standards of care, and determine what constitutes legitimate medical purpose within their respective states.
  • “The practice of medicine is regulated by State Medical Boards in each state. In the United States, there is no federal regulation of the practice of medicine.” (p. 4)
  • “The power of a state to make reasonable provisions for determining the qualifications of those engaging in the practice of medicine, and punishing those who attempt to engage therein in defiance of such statutory provisions, is not open to question.” Reetz v. People of State of Michigan, 188 U.S. 505, 505, 23 S. Ct. 390, 391, 47 L. Ed. 563 (1903).” (p. 5)
  • Need for Criminal Referral: The brief strongly advocates for a requirement that federal prosecutors obtain a criminal referral from the relevant state medical board before initiating prosecutions related to “scope of practice.” This, they argue, would ensure that such cases are based on a consensus view of medical professionals, not just the opinion of a hired expert aligned with the prosecutor’s hunch.
  • “FEDERAL PROSECUTORS NEED A CRIMINAL REFERRAL FROM STATE MEDICAL BOARDS PRIOR TO INITIATING PROSECUTION FOR CHARGES RELATING TO ‘SCOPE OF PRACTICE’” (p. 7 – Heading of Argument II)
  • “A collective consent and referral from the state’s medical board must be a prerequisite to each and every criminal prosecution against a physician who is accused of practicing medicine outside the scope of professional practice.” (p. 8)
  • State Boards as Neutral Bodies: The PAA highlights that state medical boards operate without the financial incentives that might influence government-hired experts, making them a more objective body to assess potential professional misconduct.

C. Consequences of Current Practices:

  • Mass Incarceration of Physicians: The brief asserts that the US is the only country in the world that is mass incarcerating physicians for “scope of practice” violations, implying a systemic problem with the way these cases are prosecuted.
  • “This formula has made US the only country in the world mass incarcerating physicians. This is not because all the criminal doctors miraculously reside in the United States, but rather, because there is something significantly wrong in the manner federal prosecutors have been allowed to litigate these cases as if they are in the “Wild West”.” (p. 2)
  • “With federal prosecutors stepping into this arena to create criminal liability against physicians by relying on differences of opinion of hired experts, the United States has now become the only country in the world mass incarcerating physicians.” (p. 5-6)
  • Disproportionate Sentencing: The PAA points out the severe sentences received by physicians in these cases, often exceeding those given to actual drug traffickers. They provide examples of physicians receiving sentences of hundreds of years or even life imprisonment.
  • “As of to date, we have physicians in federal prisons who are sentenced to 327 years… life… life… life… and countless more serving 20 years plus for prescribing controlled substances that a government hired expert believed was outside the scope of professional practice. Even the most prolific drug traffickers with known criminal enterprises that expand over several continents and in existence for decades do not get these stiff penalties.” (p. 9)
  • Offense to Due Process: The brief argues that these prosecutions, based on unfettered prosecutorial discretion and paid expert opinions without state medical board input, are offensive to due process and the basic tenets of a civilized society.
  • “Both the conviction and the sentence is offensive to due process and basic tenets of a civilized society because both the conviction and the sentence is based on the whimsical notion of a prosecutor’s unfettered discretion and a paid expert opinion.” (p. 4)

D. Retroactive Application of Ruan Decision:

  • Violation of Fundamental Rights: The PAA argues that if the Supreme Court rules in favor of Ruan, that decision should have full retroactive effect because the current prosecution practices violate fundamental rights to a fair trial.
  • “Full retroactive effect should be considered by the Court due to the fact that criminal prosecutions initiated by federal prosecutors against physicians regarding charges involving scope of practice all are rooted in prosecutorial overreach violating fundamental rights of the accused to a fair trial.” (p. 9)
  • Legal Precedent: They cite Griffith v. Kentucky to support the argument that a newly declared constitutional rule should apply to criminal cases pending on direct review.
  • “See Griffith v. Kentucky, 479 U.S. 314, 107 S. Ct. 708, 93 L. Ed. 2d 649 (1987), holding that failure to apply newly declared constitutional rule to criminal cases pending on direct review would violate basic norms of constitutional adjudication.” (p. 9)

Frequently Asked Questions Regarding Federal Prosecution of Physicians for “Scope of Practice”

1. What is the central concern raised by Physicians Against Abuse (PAA) regarding the prosecution of physicians for issues related to their medical practice?

PAA’s primary concern is the increasing number of federal prosecutions against physicians for “scope of practice” charges, particularly involving the prescription of controlled substances. They argue that these prosecutions often rely on the subjective opinions of government-hired experts, leading to the criminalization of conduct that should be addressed, if at all, by state medical boards, which are the proper regulatory bodies for medical practice.

2. Why does PAA believe that federal prosecutors are overreaching in these “scope of practice” cases?

PAA contends that the practice of medicine is constitutionally and historically the purview of state medical boards, which are responsible for setting standards of care and determining what constitutes legitimate medical practice. They argue that federal prosecutors, by initiating criminal charges based on their interpretation of “not for a legitimate medical purpose” and the opinions of their hired experts, are improperly intruding into state affairs without the necessary expertise or understanding of medical nuances.

3. What is PAA’s criticism of the role of expert witnesses in these federal prosecutions?

PAA criticizes the reliance on government-hired experts, often not specialists in the same field as the accused physician, whose opinions can be influenced by the prosecutor’s objectives and the government’s financial resources. They argue that a “war of experts” in court should not be the basis for criminal liability, especially when the consequences include significant prison sentences. They suggest that these experts essentially validate a prosecutor’s “hunch” rather than providing an objective assessment of medical practice.

4. What does PAA propose as a necessary prerequisite for federal prosecution of physicians in “scope of practice” cases?

PAA strongly advocates for a requirement that federal prosecutors obtain a criminal referral from the relevant state medical board before initiating any prosecution against a physician for charges related to practicing outside the scope of professional practice. They believe this would ensure that medical expertise is involved in determining whether conduct warrants criminal charges and would prevent prosecutors from acting unilaterally based on subjective interpretations.

5. According to PAA, what are some of the negative consequences of the current approach to prosecuting physicians for “scope of practice” issues?

PAA highlights several negative consequences, including the mass incarceration of physicians in the United States (unparalleled globally), excessively harsh prison sentences that often exceed those given to actual drug traffickers, the erosion of due process, and the potential for overzealous prosecutors to target wealthy physicians. They also suggest that this environment can discourage physicians from treating patients with legitimate pain management needs.

6. How does PAA connect the opioid crisis to the increased prosecution of physicians?

PAA argues that federal prosecutors are capitalizing on the ongoing opioid crisis and public sentiment to pursue “scope of practice” charges against physicians, often appealing to the emotions of juries. They believe that prosecutors are attempting to place the blame for the crisis on physicians by portraying them as greedy drug pushers, even when their prescribing practices might fall within a debatable area of medical judgment.

7. Why does PAA argue that the Supreme Court’s decision in Ruan v. United States should have retroactive effect?

PAA believes that past convictions based on the unfettered discretion of prosecutors and the opinions of their hired experts violated the fundamental rights of physicians to a fair trial. They argue that applying the Ruan decision retroactively is necessary to correct these injustices and ensure that individuals convicted under potentially flawed interpretations of the law receive appropriate reconsideration of their cases.

8. What is PAA’s overall vision for how issues of physician conduct related to scope of practice should be addressed?

PAA envisions a system where state medical boards, as the expert regulatory bodies for medical practice, have the primary role in evaluating physician conduct. They believe that these boards, operating without the financial incentives of government-hired experts, are best positioned to determine when a physician’s actions fall outside acceptable professional standards and warrant disciplinary action, including, when appropriate, a referral for criminal prosecution. This approach, they argue, would respect the division of power between state and federal authorities and ensure due process for physicians.

RUSSO

Leave a Reply