THE UNITED STATES FIFTH CIRCUIT COURT OF APPEALS IN NEUMANNS’ PHARMACY OF TALLULAH, LOUISIANA, SOUNDLY REJECTED DEA’s “CORRESPONDING RESPONSIBILITY”& USUAL COURSE OF PROFESSIONAL PRACTICE (short)

Image of a legal slide titled 'Neumann's Pharmacy v. DEA' discussing the agency authority in controlled substance dispensing, featuring a background of pharmacy bottles and a depiction of scales of justice.

“..The court soundly rejected the Drug Enforcement Administration’s (DEA) interpretation of “red flags” because the agency attempted to use them to lower the legal standard for pharmacist liability, effectively rewriting its own regulations. Specifically, the court’s rejection centered on how the DEA applied red flags to two key regulations: Corresponding Responsibility and the Usual Course of Professional Practice..”

youarewithinthenorms.com

NORMAN J CLEMENT RPH., DDS, NORMAN L. CLEMENT PHARM-TECH, MALACHI F. MACKANDAL PHARMD, IN THE SPIRIT OF WALTER R. CLEMENT MS., MBA., BELINDA BROWN-PARKER, IN THE SPIRIT OF JOSEPH SOLVO ESQ., IN THE SPIRIT OF REV. C.T. VIVIAN, JELANI ZIMBABWE CLEMENT, BS., MBA., IN THE SPIRIT OF WILLIE GUINYARD BS., IN THE SPIRIT OF ERLIN CLEMENT SR.,  JOSEPH WEBSTER MD., MBA, IN THE SPIRIT OF RICHARD KAUL, MD., BEVERLY C. PRINCE MD., FACS., IN THE SPIRIT OF LEROY BAYLOR,   JAY K. JOSHI MD., MBA, ADRIENNE EDMUNDSON, IN THE SPIRIT OF WALTER F. WRENN III, MD.,  ESTER HYATT PH.D., WALTER L. SMITH BS., IN THE SPIRIT OF BRAHM FISHER ESQ., MICHELE ALEXANDER MD., CUDJOE WILDING BS, MARTIN NDJOU, BS., RPH., IN THE SPIRIT OF DEBRA LYNN SHEPHERD, BERES E. MUSCHETT, STRATEGIC ADVISORS

WHEN AN AGENCY SUBSTITUTES A DIFFERENT RULE OF DECISION

“..we do not defer- we set the action aside..”

The DEA acted as an unregulated medical agency policing medical facilities and medical practices without legal standards or grounds.  A pharmacist is a licensed practitioner who has advanced knowledge of the chemical and physical properties of drugs and their available dosage forms.

Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals vacated a DEA order

In this judicial opinion, the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals vacated a DEA order that had revoked a pharmacy’s registration, ruling that the agency overstepped its authority by misinterpreting its own regulations.

Infographic illustrating the two-step process of the DEA's failed proof regarding invalid prescriptions. Step 1 details 'The Physician's Duty' questioning if prescriptions were issued outside professional practice, with a note stating it was 'NOT PROVEN.' Step 2 covers 'The Pharmacist's Duty,' asking if the pharmacist knowingly filled an invalid prescription, highlighting the DEA's focus on the pharmacist while skipping Step 1.

The court clarified that under the corresponding-responsibility rule, a pharmacist is only liable if they knowingly fill an invalid prescription, rejecting the DEA’s attempt to use an objective “reason to know” standard.

Diagram explaining that negligence is not a federal felony, highlighting key concepts like state standard of care and civil negligence/malpractice, with a quote from Justice Alito.

Furthermore, the judges determined that acting outside the usual course of professional practice requires more than mere negligence; it implies a total departure from professional conduct, such as acting as a drug “pusher” rather than a healthcare provider.

Infographic explaining the misapplication of Louisiana's family prescribing ban, featuring a pharmacist filling a prescription and a physician prescribing to family, along with relevant legal and factual statements.

By equating state-law standards of care with federal felony violations and misapplying local statutes, the DEA effectively rewrote existing rules without proper authorization.

Infographic titled 'A Local Pharmacy Faces the Corporate Death Penalty,' detailing Neumann's Pharmacy's owner, Laura Neumann, and the timeline of events leading to a DEA investigation and potential deregistration.

Consequently, the case was remanded, emphasizing that while the DEA has broad discretion to protect the public, it must strictly adhere to the governing text of the law.

Close-up of a gavel and a scale of justice with the text 'DEA overreach' in the foreground.

a foundational victory for registrants against regulatory overreach

The February 13, 2026, ruling by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit in Neumann’s Pharmacy, L.L.C. v. Drug Enforcement Administration represents a foundational victory for registrants against regulatory overreach.

A group of armed DEA agents in tactical black uniforms and masks, standing alert on an urban street.
DEA regulatory overreach

This decision serves as a decisive strategic check on the Drug Enforcement Administration’s (DEA) attempts to “quietly rewrite” its regulations through enforcement actions rather than formal rulemaking.

By vacating a deregistration order under the Administrative Procedure Act (APA), the court re-established the primacy of regulatory text, affirming that agency actions must be set aside if they are “arbitrary, capricious… or otherwise not in accordance with law.”

🔓 🔓 🔓 

ALL WATCHED OVER BY MACHINES OF LOVING GRACE

HUNTED BY DOJ-DEA

Close-up image of a person's face with short, wavy hair and visible blue eyes.

BE SURE TO DONATE TO THE MARK IBSEN GOFUNDME DEFENSE FUND, WHERE THE SON ALWAYS RISES!!!

Graphic promoting donations for legal defense, featuring the title 'You Are Within The Norms', website link, and donation methods including Zelle and Cash App.
DONATION

OUR TREE OF KNOWLEDGE SHALL NEVER BE SUPPRESSED

A diagram illustrating the 'Tree of Knowledge System' featuring various branches, including Culture, Mind, Life, and Matter, and their relation to the fields of Social Sciences, Psychology, Biology, and Physical Sciences.
The Tree of Knowledge System
Text graphic emphasizing the importance of eliminating the Controlled Substances Act (CSA) to address public health issues and inhumane treatment of patients.
Opioid Restrictions Drive Patients to Fentanyl
Mind map illustrating the complex relationship between opium, corruption, and contradictions in Afghanistan, highlighting topics such as DEA operations, the US military's role, and drug policy impacts.
A bottle of OxyContin 40 mg, an extended-release pain medication, displayed on a pharmacy counter. The bottle contains 100 tablets and has a warning label indicating that a medication guide must be provided upon dispensing.
OXYCONTIN

FOR NOW, YOU ARE WITHIN

YOUAREWITHINTHENORMS.COM, BENJAMIN CLEMENTINE “THE NEMESIS” LONDON, ENGLAND 2015

THE NORMS

REFERENCES:

A slide titled 'References & Further Reading' featuring a list of authors, works, and topics related to medicine, law, social architecture, and case law.
skull and bones

HUNTED BY DOJ-DEA

A smiling man wearing glasses, with a city skyline in the background.
Jewish Maryland doctor Ron Elfenbein,MD indicted for health care fraud, Convicted case overturned and dismissed
Jesse BermanMay 3, 2022
“HEALERS INTO SUSPECTS” MEDICINE, LAW, AND CORPORATE INTEREST

HUNTED BY DOJ-DEA

An advertisement for the show 'On Point with Juandolyn Stokes' featuring an exclusive interview about the criminalization of Black and Brown doctors. Includes images and names of featured doctors and details of the broadcast.
Waok, “if you torture the data for long enough, you can make them say anything.”…I believe that is exactly what USDOJ, CDC, and DEA have been doing with their deliberate conflation and mischaracterization of research results on medical prescribing versus opioid-involved overdose mortality.

…richard lawhern ph.d
Three individuals in white coats stand with their backs to the viewer, each featuring a stylized target on their backs, against a background of floating capsules and abstract patterns.
HUNTED

HUNTED BY DOJ-DEA

Image showing two doctors, John P. Couch and Xiulu Ruan, with a headline about the Supreme Court dismissing their conviction in a pill mill case.
THE HOLY TRINITY
Three figurines resembling religious figures with halos are standing around a pile of various prescription medication bottles and pills.

THE HOLY TRINITY ON TRIAL DISTORTION

HUNTED BY DOJ-DEA

Four individuals standing together outdoors near a blue metal picnic table, with buildings and trees in the background.
ALL THESE PHYSICIANS SEEN HERE HAVE BEEN TARGETED CRIMINALLY FOR PRESCRIBING F.D.A APPROVED NARCOTIC ANALGESIC MEDICATION: TRIAL OF (LEFT TO RIGHT) DR. NEIL ANAND, MD, INTERVENTIONAL ANESTHESIOLOGIST, DR. MARK IBSEN, MD, EMERGENCY MEDICINE MONTANA, DR. MOHAMMED ALY RIFIA, MD., PSYCHIATRIST, DR. CHRISTOPHER R. RUSSO, MD, INTERVENTIONAL ANESTHESIOLOGIST, TAKEN DURING ANAND’S TRIAL CITY OF BENJAMIN FRANKLIN

1 Comment

Leave a Reply